Friday - July 21, 2017
Home    About    Writers    Links    Contact     RSS

About the Author

Bobby McMahon

Bobby McMahon

You can see me on Soccer Central most Mondays and Thursdays on Rogers Sportsnet in Canada. I write a regular column for and and frequently guest on various podcasts and radio shows.


How Good Were These Players?

Written by on February 3, 2011 | 3 Comments »
Posted in History and Books

Colin Jose’s piece on Thursday covered the short history of the Eastern Canada Professional Soccer League in the early 60s.

Although it is often mentioned that we see very little of a close season nowadays, it is worth remembering that players from 30 years ago and before often spent 11 months of the year playing as well. (During the heyday of the NASL some players played 12 months of the year with no break).

The biggest difference is that without global television their extended seasons often went unnoticed to most with the possible exceptions of local newspapers that might send a reporter on tour.

As Colin described, players from other countries would often travel to North America, South Africa, Australia (essentially new countries with relatively large immigrant populations) to play on loan deals for the summer.

In some cases players would opt to move to one of these countries as the end of their careers drew closer.

There were also overseas tours that teams undertook for extended period of times during the summer. Today you might have a team visit North America for a couple of weeks – years ago it would be unusual to have a tour last less than four weeks with most stretching to six weeks or more.

Sometimes special tournaments would be arranged with other touring sides or teams factored existing tournaments into their schedule. I can vaguely remember Dundee traveling to play in the USA in the summer of 1962.

Later in the 60s teams were invited to represent US and Canadian cities and the competition would form the basis for the North American Soccer League.

And it was not only club teams. Countries would often tour their full international teams or a “B” squad of players.

What I found intriguing about Colin’s article were the calibre of players that a fledgling league such as the ECPSL attracted. These were not run of the mill players or players desperately looking to cash a few extra pay cheques at the end of their careers.

Here are pen pics of the players he mentioned.

Stanley Matthews

Matthews may have been 46 when he played in the summer of 1961 but only five years before he had won the European Player of the Year trophy and it would be another 9 years before he played his last professional game.

To say that he was a physical phenomenon would to easily dismiss his total commitment to fitness and conditioning. He was the David Beckham of his day without the pop-culture baggage. He remains the oldest player to have played in both the English top flight and for the national team.

Danny Blanchflower

Blanchflower arrived in Canada having just captained Tottenham Hotspur to the domestic double – the first English club to do so in the 20th century. He had also been voted England’s Player of the Year, an honour he had also earned in 1958.

He captained Northern Ireland to a place in the quarter finals of the 1958 World Cup.

Blanchflower is still regarded as one of the best passers ever to grace the game in the UK and one of only a handful of players who could also be thought of as “thinkers” and insightful contributors once he retired.

Upon his return to Tottenham he would lead Spurs to a repeat of their FA Cup win.

Jackie Mudie

A Scottish international who played in the 1958 World Cup Mudie had signed for Blackpool from Dundee junior football just after WW2.

He spent 15 years with Blackpool playing much of it with Stanley Matthews and was a key part of Blackpool’s 1953 FA Cup win.

Mudie was 31 when he played in the ECPSL and would play for another six seasons in England with Stoke City and finally Port Vale.

Johnny Haynes

Haynes was the first footballer to appear for England in every class of football available – school, youth, under 23, `B` and full international level. He was also captain of England when he traveled to play in Canada in 1961.

Around the same time the maximum wage in England was abolished and Haynes became England’s first £100 per week footballer – an outlandish sum at the time.

Regarded as the best player ever to appear in a Fulham strip Haynes career was to be impacted by an accident in 1962. It kept him out of football for a year and many believe that if it had not been for the accident Haynes would have captained England in the 1966 World Cup.

Tommy Younger

A Scotland international goalkeeper Younger made his name as part of the great Hibernian team of the early 50s. Younger moved to Liverpool but returned to Scottish football as player/manager of Falkirk.

However, after a year he returned to England – this time with Stoke. After his stint with Toronto City, Younger played for Don Revie at Leeds United before retiring in 1963.

A different time and certainly something that cannot be repeated. Nonetheless these players were all stars of their day – Matthews, Blanchflower and Haynes arguably some of the best who have ever played the game.

You can get updates through RSS (top of the page), follow at Twitter BobbySoccerRep, or on Facebook

3 responses to “How Good Were These Players?”

  1. Soccerlogical says:

    Bobby – From what you know of G Neville, is there anyhting indicating he would make an intelligent and insightful analyst/commentator. From watching him on the field and interviewed, I never detected any wit, humor or insight the likes a Roy Keane or Shmeichel provides.

  2. Manager material – wrote a column about three years ago suggesting that Carragher and Neville would become mangers.

  3. Tom Boardman . says:

    Matthews and Mudie were part of Blackpools three Ms as it was once called.

    Stanley Matthews and Mortensen and Jackie Mudie. I played against him a couple of times when he was in the B team prior to going into the stiffs then the first team, he was a smart player very underrated, in fact he was a great link between Matthews and Mortensen. In the F A cup it was a foul on Jackie that Morty scored the free kick, tied up the game .

    Danny B was a great Player, for the Spurs and N Ireland and certainly glad you included Younger he was a good keeper, all these guys could be starters now for any of the top four Premier teams. I personally think Matthews was even better than Beckham, he never fouled and could score goals when needed as in the preceding games to the cup run in 53.

    He had the ability to flight the ball in so many ways , hard dives across the goal , floaters to the far post and a great fantastic cross field pass to the opposite wingers, I think the last twenty minutes showed his talent, but there was a small guy driving it – Ernie Taylor who later played for Man U .

    Jackie was a painter and decorators apprentice before he signed pro forms, and that was when they were paid ten pounds a week an extra pound if they drew and two pounds for their win.

    In his last years in league one when Matthews played away from home, ground records were broken for league games that was his fan standing , and is indicative of Pele’s statement , “he taught us how to play football.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

House Rules

Please refrain from posting comments that;

  • Attempt to demean, intimidate or bully fellow readers
  • Are racist, sexist, homophobic, sexually explicit, intolerant or otherwise abusive
  • Includes language likely to offend or attempts to try and circumvent this request
  • Could be considered spam

The House reserves the right to delete any such comments and to block further participation on the site.

Soccer Report Extra
© copyright 2010. All rights reserved.
Designed and Developed by:
Bills'eye + Underscorefunk Design