Much of the pre-game chatter revolved around Landon Donovan not making the starting line up. Perhaps the more critical decision was the change in formation – at least initially.
Rather than the more normal 4-2-2-2, US coach Bob Bradley started with a 4-2-3-1 set up with Bradley and Jones sitting deep in midfield with Kljestan wide on the left; Dempsey in the centre and Bedoya withdrawn on the right. Altidore started as a lone striker.
There was a lot of confusion surrounding Jamaica’s starting formation. Was it three at the back or was it four in defence? The answer perhaps was that it was both and neither.
Although the team was announced as playing in three banks they more often than not tried to play with four banks when in possession – two up front with three midfield players in support, then Austin playing as a defensive shield and the two full backs pushing forward which left the two centre backs.
When defending it was more often a back four than a back three. However, as the game progressed the level of sophistication required to successfully move from one formation to another began to breakdown in the face of the superior US technique.
And that was really the story of this game. It wasn’t about Landon Donovan not starting, or formations or Jamaica’s pace, it was just about the USA having better players who passed the ball better and moved off the ball better.
We can only guess what a difference it might have made to the final outcome if Ryan Johnson or Shelton had scored in the first few minutes when both were left one on one with Tim Howard. Howard saved the first and the second attempt has yet to land. Perhaps the USA might have panicked, Jamaica might have defended doggedly.
But it would turn out to be Jamaica’s best chance of the match as the USA dominated proceedings for the rest of the game. Only Donovan Ricketts stood between his side and a pummeling.
Player Ratings (1 – low 10 – high)
Tim Howard – 7, earned his coin today with the opening save while everything else was routine.
Steve Cherundolo – 6, had acres of space to operate in – especially in the first half – but too often he hesitated to put in an early ball or his final pass fell short.
Clarence Goodson – 5, still not totally convincing at the centre back position. There were moments that would have cost the US dear against better opposition.
Carlos Bocanegra – 7, any doubt that the pace of the Jamaica attack might prove to be too much was quickly put to bed with his reading of the game and overall anticipation. Solid in the air and on the deck.
Eric Lichaj – 5, I am afraid that I do not see what others appear to see in Lichaj at left back. He does have some pace and gets forward nicely against lesser opposition. However, having a left back who can barely kick with their left foot hardly makes him the ideal candidate for the left back position.And what about the two throw-ins he took that he threw across the front of his own penalty area? For goodness sake has someone never told him that this is a cardinal sin?
Michael Bradley – 6, another less than sterling performance at this edition of the Gold Cup. Effort is not lacking but lack of game time while at Aston Villa might be the cause. Caught in possession a couple of times too often and his passing was ultra-conservative. However, his positional play and general awareness pulled him through.
Jermaine Jones (out 75th) – 8, without a shadow of a doubt his best performance for the US to date. Even without the shot that led to the opening goal and the breakaway that resulted in Jermaine Taylor being sent off he was still the afternoon’s outstanding performer.
Alejandro Bedoya (out 65th) – 6, made some good runs from his starting position wide on the right. Plays with great intelligence and his adaptability should make him a regular member of the international squad.
Clint Dempsey – 7, presented a real and present danger throughout the match to Jamaica. Finally got the goal his efforts deserved.
Sacha Kljestan -7, had one of his better matches for the USA and as the match wore on he grew stronger and more confident. A switch from a wide position on the left to a central position during much of the second half seemed to suit him.
Jozy Altidore (out 11th) – NR after going down with what looked like a hamstring problem
Juan Agudelo (in 11th) – 7, played very well after replacing Altidore early in the game. Led the US line, worked hard to retain possession and had enough strength and pace to constantly bother the Jamaica defence.
Landon Donovan – (on 65th) – 6, contributed to the second goal and proved to be an ideal player as the USA set about managing the game to a successful conclusion.
Maurice Edu (in 75th) – 6, linked well when he came into the game and got forward for a crack at goal.
The Red Card
I don’t believe the replay of the incident when Jermaine Taylor was adjudged to have taken down Jermaine Jones as he broke clear was conclusive one way or another. Certainly it could not be used to prove that no contact was made.
The secondary point is that no contact is required in order for the referee to blow for an infringement – something that many seem to be missing from many comments.
A tertiary point is that Taylor failed to question the referee’s decision (as far as I could see anyway) – surely something to be considered before questioning the official’s decision?
You can also find other Soccer Report Extra.com contributors on Twitter by following this link.
Please refrain from posting comments that;
The House reserves the right to delete any such comments and to block further participation on the site.