Tuesday - July 25, 2017
Home    About    Writers    Links    Contact     RSS

About the Author



That Was A Blunder, Sigi, Not A Mistake

Written by on July 24, 2011 | 8 Comments »
Posted in Seattle Sounders

Feisty George Galloway framed it adequately when he declared the decision to invade Iraq as a blunder, not a mistake.

Likewise, Sigi Schmid, manager of the Seattle Sounders Football Club in Major League Soccer gifted the league his own blunder when his side met Manchester United Football Club Wednesday evening, July 20th, as part of the 2011 World Football Challenge.

To err is human.  Mistakes happen.  But a blunder is a special case, in my book, that fulfills two conditions.

a) The mistake was easily preventable.

b) The impact of the error is significant.

First half line-ups:

Manchester United: G – Lindegaard, D – Rafael Da Silva, Vidic, Ferdinand, Evra, M – Nani, Anderson, Giggs, Young, F – Owen, Macheda

Seattle Sounders [2011 season min played]: G – Keller [1,800 min], D – Riley [1,589 min], Parke [1,389 min] , Ianni [794 min], Gonzalez [898 min], M – Rosales [1,043 min], Alonso [1,800 min], Friberg [1,201 min], Fernandez [1,011 min], F – Levesque [587 min], Montero [1,257 min]

2nd half line-ups:

Manchester United: G – Amos, D – Rafael Da Silva, Evans (in 56), Ferdinand, Fabio Da Silva (in 56), M – Obertan (in 56), Anderson, Park, Carrick (in 66), F – Diouf, Rooney

Seattle Sounders [2011 season min played]: G – Boss [90 min], D – Tetteh (in 64) [90 min], Graham (in 64) [90 min], Scott [398 min], M – Estrada (in 73) [61 min], Carrasco [455 min], Evans/Seamon (Evans injured out 64) [Avg 554 min], Noonan/ Ngassa (Ngassa in 76) [Avg 38 min], Neagle [405 min], F – Jaqua/ Montano (Montano in 76) [Avg 394 min] , Fucito [551 min]

Sounders 1rst half team competitive minutes played in 2011: 64% of total.

Sounders 2nd half team competitive minutes played in 2011: 15% of total.

First half goals:  United 1, Sounders 0.

Second half goals: United 6, Sounders 0.

Therefore, Sigi decided to field a team that he has used in only 15% of all competitive minutes this year for most of the second half in front of a record crowd in the Pacific Northwest for soccer of over 67K.  The competitive minutes played this year of his second half goalie and defenders are especially low.

Now, Sigi is not the first manager to bench starters in the second half.  Steve Nicol also made several changes to his New England Revolution line-up to rest starters in a game against Manchester United exactly a week before this game, even if not as drastic in terms of competitive minutes played.

In Steve’s case, he had a competitive league game the following Saturday night and the team was trying to arrest a 9 game losing streak.

Sigi faced a different set of circumstances.  Seattle was scheduled to play the Philadelphia Union on Saturday, July 23 at the beginning of the year.

However, on May 19th, Major League Soccer rescheduled the game for October 8th to accommodate the Union’s game against Real Madrid for the World Football Challenge.

Seattle’s next game, therefore, is against San Francisco FC of Panama away for the CONCACAF CL on July 26, 6 days after the game with United; a normal break between games if he played his starters throughout.

Sigi admitted as much in his post-match conference quotes.  He was delayed in his appearance before the conference, and according to the Seattle Soccer blog “Prost Amerika Soccer”, he appeared chastened and “drained” when he did appear amid rumors of an unhappy owner, Joe Roth, having a word with him in the locker room.

“I need to apologize to our fans because I thought we embarrassed ourselves in the second half, not to take anything away from Man United because they’re a great team. They scored some great goals and their movement was superb. We wanted to reward all the guys on the team, wanted to play everybody. I think in retrospect that was a mistake. I should have played guys and brought some guys off the bench and not tried to get everybody in the game. We’ve had a hard season. We’ve worked very hard and played very well and I wanted to reward all the guys with the opportunity to get on the field against Man United. Unfortunately they didn’t reward themselves.”

So the first condition of this blunder was fulfilled by the accommodating schedule.

The second reason Sigi’s moves were a blunder is due to the unique position the sport of soccer holds in the US relative to the rest of the world.

Everyone who cares about the sport here from the fans, management, soccer media and players, have an additional responsibility to be ambassadors and promoters of the sport beyond their normal roles for major sports.

Those who deride this friendly too easily neglect to recognize the importance of events that bring a large number of “eyeballs” to watch the sport.

The triage of this event was offset by more competitive games in other Word Football Challenge games, but I think lessons were learned from Sigi’s blunder which is probably the best one can say about blunders.

You can get updates through RSS (top of the page), follow at Twitter BobbySoccerRep, or on Facebook SoccerReportExtra.com

You can also find other Soccer Report Extra.com contributors on Twitter by following this link.

8 responses to “That Was A Blunder, Sigi, Not A Mistake”

  1. Soccerlogical says:

    Is it really a “blunder” to reward your entire squad with minutes against one of the best teams in the world in what is nothing more than a training session? The guys Sigi put in for the 2nd half give it their all every day in training and get paid an avg of 35K a year.

    I don’t think Seattle fans will remember the “training session” in a weeks time once CONCACAF CL starts, let alone once they start the playoffs for the MLS Cup.

  2. John Bladen says:

    While the result was an embarrassment (and perhaps a PR nightmare for the club, we’ll see), I don’t agree that this can be categorized as a blunder.

    Anyone watching the other “WFC” games with a critical eye can see that Real, Man U and the others have worked to keep the games close. They are being well paid for their summer tour of America and no-one is in any doubt that they are light years ahead of their MLS competition. It’s not an insult for an MLS club to be outclassed by the likes of Real Madrid or Manchester United. It’s just a footballing reality.

    Perhaps some fans will be turned off by the one sided result, but I doubt any of those were (or were likely to become) regular MLS attendees anyway.

  3. ARBEITER says:


    I am not sure these clubs are being quite as charitable as you make out. New England and Seattle were quite competitive in the first halves until they pulled their starters.

    Man City tied the Galaxy and beat the Whitecaps by a goal. Real Madrid weren’t able to score against Mexican side Chivas de until the 77th minute and Ronaldo worked very hard to open up the Mexican side for 3 quick goals.

    The Union finished their game against RM 2-1.

    Undoubtedly, the big European sides are in pre-season form and are not playing as hard as they will play in their leagues. The gulf in class is enormous. However, when teams have played their starters, North American teams have kept the games close.

  4. Soccerlogical says:

    “The gulf in class is enormous. However, when teams have played their starters, North American teams have kept the games close.”

    You’re kidding right? You actually believe Galaxy without Lando and Angel would be a tough test for Man City if this were a competitive match? This is your second article regarding friendlies where we are all trying to tell you that they are nothing more than glorified training sessions and media ops.

    Balotelli was taken off the second he pulled an overly arrogant Marseille turn attempt on goal against Galaxy. Mancini had to take him off because the “US Tours” are not meant to diminish MLS soccer but simply make the games exciting whether by Ronlado scoring hat tricks or a few “close games” here and there.

  5. ARBEITER says:

    No, I don’t think it would be a “tough test”. But I don’t think it was an exercise in charity either.

    Thanks for the feedback.

  6. Brian says:

    It’s not a blunder to keep your second choice players involved in a meaningless friendly before going into a (hopefully) packed 2nd half of the season. It’s called good squad management.

  7. Brian says:

    No, a blunder would be leaving a Freddy Montero or Brad Davis on the pitch for 90 mins to try to win this meaningless friendly and having them get injured and be unable to participate in the CONCACAF Champions League, US Open Cup and MLS regular season… competitions that, you know, actually matter.

  8. Brian says:

    No, a blunder would be leaving a Freddy Montero or Brad Davis on the pitch for 90 mins to try to win this meaningless friendly and having them get injured and be unable to participate in the CONCACAF Champions League, US Open Cup and MLS regular season… competitions that, you know, actually matter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

House Rules

Please refrain from posting comments that;

  • Attempt to demean, intimidate or bully fellow readers
  • Are racist, sexist, homophobic, sexually explicit, intolerant or otherwise abusive
  • Includes language likely to offend or attempts to try and circumvent this request
  • Could be considered spam

The House reserves the right to delete any such comments and to block further participation on the site.

Soccer Report Extra
© copyright 2010. All rights reserved.
Designed and Developed by:
Bills'eye + Underscorefunk Design