Sunday - July 23, 2017
Home    About    Writers    Links    Contact     RSS

About the Author

Bobby McMahon

Bobby McMahon

You can see me on Soccer Central most Mondays and Thursdays on Rogers Sportsnet in Canada. I write a regular column for and and frequently guest on various podcasts and radio shows.


Tightest Premier League Battle To Avoid Drop – What About 2005?

Written by on May 20, 2011 | 6 Comments »
Posted in English Premier League

As we get older the mind can start to play tricks. But it looks as if relegation battles can play tricks as well on commentators, pundits and bloggers.

How else can you explain so many people telling us that we are going into the final Sunday of the season with the closest relegation battle ever in Premier League history?

One point separate five teams which certainly make things tight but West Ham have already been relegated.

We have Wigan, Blackpool and Birmingham all of 39 points and Wolves and Blackburn both on 40 points. Cutting to the chase it means that three of these five teams will survive.

That gives a survival rate of 60% which is pretty decent odds. I think a case can be made that the last day of the 2004/05 season was just as tight, perhaps more so.

Cast your mind back just six years – it really is not that long ago.

With one game remaining the bottom of the Premier League looked like this.

Norwich               33

Southampton      32

Crystal Palace     32

West Brom          31

Three of the 4 teams were going to be relegated while only one would survive. If you were in that sort of situation what survival odds would you prefer – 60% (2011 season) or 25% (2005 season)?

Not difficult is it.

The final games took Norwich to Fulham (mid-table), Palace to the Valley to play Charlton (mid-table), Southampton hosted Manchester United (3rd) while West Brom was at home to Portsmouth (16th but safe).

Norwich were considered to be favorites to survive given that a win ensured another Premier League season.

Southampton were next as far as the odds makers were concerned although it was complicated. They needed Norwich and West Brom not to win and to match Crystal Palace’s result as long as it was at least a draw.

Survival in such a scenario would come from goal difference – a margin that could have been as slim as one goal.

Crystal Palace needed to win and to hope other results went their way. Meanwhile West Brom had no other option but to go for a win and to hope that Norwich would lose while Southampton and Crystal Palace do no better than draw.

As it turned out things turn ugly very early for the favorites. Norwich went 1-0 down to an early Brian McBride goal and by half time they were 2-0 down and by full time it had turned into a 6-0 rout.

Reality quickly dawned and Norwich’s hopes of another Premier League season now depended on West Brom not winning and both Southampton and Crystal Palace losing.

A draw for either Palace or Southampton would not help Norwich on account of a vastly inferior goal difference.

Southampton had been buoyed by a John O’Shea own goal early in the game but  Darren Fletcher equalized before 20 minutes were up.

News from the Valley was better as Charlton lead 1-0 and it was good from the Hawthorns as well with West Brom and Pompey scoreless.

However, it did not take long for things to take a turn or two for the worst for Norwich and their fans.

At the 58th minute of two games Dougie Freedman equalized for Palace while Geoff Horsfield gave West Brom a 1-0 lead. If these results held Palace would be safe.

Palace were offered a margin of safety when Ruud van Nistelrooy scored what would be the winner for United at Southampton. It was a result that sealed Southampton’s fate.

But in the space of four minutes things changed again. Fortune equalized for Charlton while Kieran Richardson doubled West Brom’s lead.

Now West Brom would be the unlikely survivor although 15 nerve racking minutes remained.

Despite the pressure there were no more goals at the Hawthorns or the Valley and West Brom’s 13 points from their last 9 games of the season secured them another season in the top flight.

Here courtesy of youtube is how things unfolded at three of the relegation matches on the last day of the 2005 season.

Fulham v Norwich

Charlton v Crystal Palace

West Brom v Portsmouth

You can get updates through RSS (top of the page), follow at Twitter BobbySoccerRep, or on Facebook

You can also find other Soccer Report contributors on Twitter by following this link.


6 responses to “Tightest Premier League Battle To Avoid Drop – What About 2005?”

  1. Erik says:

    Let’s use this as the place for us all to put our Relegation predictions. I say the 2 that get sent down are:

    Birmingham: I don’t see any way they get even 1 point @ Totty on Sunday

    BUT – in order for them to go DOWN that means I need Blackpool or Wigan staying UP. I say B’ham is joined by:

    Wigan: I think they finished tied with Blackpool and go down on GD. If B’ham loses and Pool are Wigan tied at 40 – that is obvious who wins that one. IF they tie at 39 I think Blackpool stays up because of more goals scored than either 2 going down. The odds say Wigan is the fave over Stoke but I’m not so sure about that. Wigan is awful on the road and I don’t see Stoke losing the game. I think B’Pool can get at least 1 point @ Old Trafford on Sunday and stay up because of it

    For the record I am rooting big time for Blackburn to go DOWN so those MORONIC Chicken Farmers can realize they are clueless and stupid if they think they have a T5 side (The fact the owners made Steve Kean fly to India and back in a roughly 24 Hour span before this massively huge game tells me how CLUELESS these guys are – how about THESE guys flying to England this one time knowing how important this game is – Imagine if Man U was in this spot – No Way in !@$%^ SAF woulda boarded a plane). But in order for B’Burn to go down they must lose and between B’ham, B’Pool and Wigan 2 of these 3 must win (unless B’Burn loses by about 8 goals – don’t see that happening) and I really don’t see that happening.

    Bobby – we’ll get your thoughts on the FSR tonite – right?

  2. Sticking with Blackburn and Blackpool

  3. Soccerlogical says:

    ERIK – What’s with the persistent postings regarding the other two teams to get relegated.. is it a fetish?

    With one game left it really doesn’t show that much acumen or insight when predicting who gets relegated… even with such a close race. Anything can happen with various permutations.

  4. Gus Keri says:


    It is how you want to look at it.

    You say that the lower the survival odds, the tighter the race.

    The way I see it is: the more teams envolved. the more exciting the race. And it is because more fans will be on the edge of their seats and more games will be nerve racking.

    In La Liga, seven teams within 3 points of the last relegation spot.
    Survival odds? 6/7 (85%)
    Less tight or more exciting than the EPL relegarion race?

  5. Grant says:

    I agree with Erik.

    The big difference between now and ’05 Bobby is the teams this year are actually winning! The points they have acquired already compared to ’05 (the previously most dramatic relegation fight) makes this one more appealing to me. I will be very surprised if there isn’t a win or two on Sunday.

  6. Gus

    I would say less because every team in Spain controls their own destiny – as weird as it sounds. I will have a wee piece up on the Liga situation later today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

House Rules

Please refrain from posting comments that;

  • Attempt to demean, intimidate or bully fellow readers
  • Are racist, sexist, homophobic, sexually explicit, intolerant or otherwise abusive
  • Includes language likely to offend or attempts to try and circumvent this request
  • Could be considered spam

The House reserves the right to delete any such comments and to block further participation on the site.

Soccer Report Extra
© copyright 2010. All rights reserved.
Designed and Developed by:
Bills'eye + Underscorefunk Design